JESUS, HOW MANY TIMES?
A First-Person Narrative Based on Matthew 18:21-22
I remember the day I asked Jesus a question that I thought had a fairly straightforward answer. Yet His response would challenge everything I thought I understood about forgiveness.
We had been listening to Jesus teach about relationships within the kingdom of heaven. He spoke often about humility, compassion, mercy, and the importance of loving one another. His teachings were beautiful, but sometimes they were difficult to understand, especially when they challenged the traditions and expectations with which we had grown up. Jesus seemed to be teaching us something much greater than what I had previously understood. His teachings seemed to require us to go further, to cost more of ourselves, to demand more than what the age-old laws demanded of us, more than what the traditions that had been passed down required of us, more than what our rabbis preached to us. His teachings forced us to see things differently … to see others differently … to see ourselves differently.
What he taught often kept me awake at night as I tossed and turned in bed trying to make sense of them. Love your enemies? Turn the other cheek? Give with no thought of recompense? These were hard lessons. And forgiveness? … I began to wonder: Where does forgiveness end? I thought about how many times someone might offend me, disappoint me, or betray my trust. What if it were someone close to me? What if it were a fellow disciple? What if that person were even a Roman? What if the same person continued to make the same mistake over and over again? Surely there must be a point when a person has forgiven enough. Surely God does not expect us to continue forgiving someone who repeatedly did us wrong, who maybe isn’t even isn’t sorry for how they hurt us.
I understood that we were expected to forgive others. Forgiveness was an important part of our religious teaching. According to the teachings of our rabbis, a person was generally expected to forgive someone three times for the same offense. After that, repeated wrongdoing was considered evidence that the offender had not truly repented. I had always thought that three times was a reasonable expectation. After all, forgiveness isn’t always easy. When someone hurts you, especially when that person does it repeatedly, it becomes increasingly difficult to put the offense aside.
But Jesus seemed to be teaching us something much greater than what I had previously understood and accepted. I needed an answer. I needed to understand the limits of forgiveness. So, I approached Jesus and asked Him: "Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me and I forgive him? As many as seven times?"
The number wasn’t arbitrary. In our Jewish tradition, certain numbers have significance. Seven is a holy number and stood for perfection, wholeness and completeness. And so, for me to forgive seven times, that is going above and beyond, isn’t it? God would be pleased with me if I forgave seven times, wouldn’t He? Would I not be holy in His eyes if I forgave that excessive number of times?
Then He looked at me – not with annoyance, not with irritability, not with disappointment, but with the patience and understanding that was characteristic of him, with those deep piercing eyes that could read the corners of my heart and of my soul.
“No, Peter,” he said emphatically. “Not seven times, but seventy times seven times.”
I was stunned. Seventy times seven times? Four hundred and ninety times? How could one forgive someone that many times? How could patience and mercy be stretched that far? But then I realized, as it was with many of his teachings, that his words were not meant to be taken literally, but perhaps allegorically; that there was more to them than what appeared on the surface; that I needed to hear, not to what his words said, but to what they meant … To hear, not so much with my ears, but with my heart.
The more I
considered His words, the more I realized that Jesus wasn’t just giving me a
larger number. He was teaching me that forgiveness was never meant to be
governed by a numerical limit. As I had used our culture’s symbolism of numbers
in my question to him, so Jesus had used it in his response to me … that the
multiplication of numbers wasn’t to be taken literally, but that it was used to
signify “infinity.” Jesus was telling me that forgiveness shouldn’t be measured
by counting the number of times someone has wronged me; that it needed to be
limitless, that the infinitely perfect response to the hurts and wrongdoings
caused by others is to forgive as God does, perfectly, without limit.
I began to think about my own weaknesses. I knew I was far from perfect. I had made mistakes, and I would undoubtedly make more. How many times had I acted out of fear, pride, or anger? Yet I continually depended upon the patience and mercy of the Lord. How often had God forgiven me? How could I expect God to be endlessly patient with me while I placed a limit on my willingness to forgive someone else?
I had approached Jesus looking for a limit, but He had given me a completely different way of thinking. Jesus was teaching us that forgiveness is not simply an obligation we fulfill a certain number of times. It is an attitude of the heart. It is an expression of mercy, compassion, humility, and love. I had asked how many times I must forgive. He was teaching me that a heart filled with God's mercy should never be keeping score, that the moment you start counting, you have already stopped forgiving.
I’m hot-tempered. I’m opinionated. I’m stubborn. Sometimes I hold anger and hurt within me. Sometimes I brood internally over what people have said … what they have done. Other times, I erupt like a volcano and lash out against those who have done me an injustice. And sometimes, I have a really difficult time forgiving myself for the things I have thought … the things I have said … the things I have done. How, then, can I forgive “seventy times seven times” as Jesus says I should? But the thing is, that’s the heart of God. That’s the way He forgives. That’s the way He has forgiven ME!
Seventy times seven times …
Who am I to do less?
